Shortcuts
  • Common Ground
  • Summer Conference
  • Residential Fellowship
  • Vocational Progamme
  • Sign Up
  • Vimeo
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Lead Programmes
    • Summer Conference
    • Residential Fellowship
    • Vocational Progamme
  • Events & Courses
    • SPACE
    • Conversation Evenings
    • Short Courses
  • Resources
    • Common Ground Magazine
    • All Articles
    • Venn Presents
  • Store
    • Books
    • Devotional Resources
  • Who We Are
    • About
    • Our Story
    • Our People
  • Donate
  • Contact
Venn Foundation
58 Hillsborough Road
Hillsborough, Auckland 1042
Email: [email protected] Phone: +6499294988
PO Box 163138
Lynfield, Auckland 1443
Xu Bing Phoenix_small
  • Link copied!

Phoenix, Work, and the Challenge of True Hope

By Julian Wood >> 3 min read
Arts, Photography, Music

Originally, artist Xu Bing was commissioned to create an atrium piece for a high-rise building in Beijing.

But, as he visited the construction site, he was deeply affected by the conditions of work and the lives of the workers themselves. The project pivoted, and the result, eventually, was a pair of six-ton mythical birds, made from castoffs from construction sites around Beijing.

Titled Phoenix 2008–2010, the birds flew headlong into controversy. For many commentators, the arrangement of unwanted iron girders, scaffolding, jackhammers, and plastic safety hats and cones brought to the fore the cost to millions of migrant workers of China’s meteoric development. And indeed, it’s a strength of the piece that it reworks the waste of this labour into a vivid testament to their suffering, and the fact that few such workers enjoy the prosperity they’ve helped to build. But Xu Bing’s decision to respond artfully to these complexities by creating two beautiful phoenix points to deeper cultural and more dangerous, ideological narrative.

Indeed, to truly understand how controversial the artwork is, one has to understand the power and symbolism of a Chinese phoenix. Feng Huang, or Chinese phoenix, do not rise from ashes like a western phoenix, but they are an auspicious symbol, combining the spiritual, economic, and the political. Their arrival heralds a new golden era for society. They pronounce the mandate of heaven. They proclaim the existence of virtue: justice, loyalty, credibility, and mercy. With this cultural understanding in mind, Phoenix not only challenges us to see the costs exacted on faraway workers by economic development or our consumption, but the symbolic artwork also proclaims an earthly kingdom. It’s a kingdom that has raised 100 million people out of poverty, but it is also a kingdom where people seek humanity’s perfection through hard work. Humanity, the belief runs, can save itself. This should give us pause.

Xu Bing Phoenix_Reduced
“Phoenix“, captured by David McSpadden at The Cathedral of St John the Divine in New York City.
“Phoenix” >>

As such, the existence of this massive and ambivalent artwork invites us to ask: are we, too, guilty of building our own mini-phoenix? The construction is often subtle and goes unnoticed. We use the short-term fruit of long hours at work. It could be an unseen-and-almost-but-not-quite-unethical business decision. It might be the wrong choice, justified in the moment by arguing that the ends will justify the means. Taken singly, such matters appear small and might be readily discarded. But they entail a cost, and, viewed together across the course of a life, will reveal one or other cobbled-together image of salvation, images that—like Xu Bing’s choice of the Feng Huang, the phoenix—will point ultimately not to a living hope, to a true salvation, but to the unstable improvisations of humanity’s kingdoms.

So even as Phoenix asks us to examine again how—and at whose expense—we come by the goods and wealth we enjoy, Xu Bing’s conflicted vision also causes us to ask more important questions: in all our working, whose kingdom are we really building? Where does our salvation truly come from?

Arts, Photography, Music
More from
Julian Wood +

Keep
Exploring

You may also
be interested in

Leaf by Niggle_feature
Leaf by Niggle
6 min read

All articles from
this edition

Fall Toil and Tower_feature
Common Ground
May 2021 Edtn

Also
on offer

Image
The Good of Work
Find out more

Common
Ground

August 2023 Edtn >>
A Reissue Special

Sign up to receive Common Ground in your inbox

Sign Up
Shortcuts
  • Common Ground Editions
  • Residential Fellowship
  • Vocational Progamme
  • Sign Up

Copyright © 2023
Venn Foundation

Venn Foundation

58 Hillsborough Road
Hillsborough, Auckland 1042

Email: [email protected]

Phone: +64 (9) 929 4988

Post: PO Box 163138
Lynfield, Auckland 1443

Venn Foundation logo
Stay in the Loop

Receive all the latest information about Venn events, resources, programmes, and updates.

Sign Up
  • Vimeo
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
Support Us

Venn Foundation is a Charitable Trust (CC28328). If you would like to support our mission and work we would love to hear from you.

Donate Now

Design by Andy Campbell

Development by Publica

Venn Foundation logo
  • Vimeo
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Copyright © 2023
Venn Foundation

Design by Andy Campbell

Development by Publica